This is a cross-posting from my facebook, but I think it bears inclusion here.
Bram graciously reopened the can of singing worms that was the playlist game I devised about four months ago. I am very excited about this, and without further ado I bring you my updated list of songs, to be downloaded at your leisure!
For those who are using last.fm and want to participate, the rules are as follows:
1. Look at the list of your top 15 artists for the last 3 months.
2. Pick one song by each artist that showcases some of your reasons for listening to them.
3. Put the songs in ascending order of (the artist's) playcount.
So here I go again, and will be pleased if anyone feels like participating. Or not. I am pleased either way.
David's List, as of 19 November 2009
DOWNLOAD IT HERE:
http://download.yousendit.com/ZW9EK0dqSEI4aVBIRGc9PQ1. Smog - Held (1999)
2. Herman Düne - Not on Top (2005)
3. Pete Seeger - Careless Love (1959)
4. Burial - Shell of Light (2007)
5. Waterson:Carthy - Flowers of Knaresborough Forest (1997)
6. The Angels of Light - Michael's White Hands (2005)
7. Bonnie 'Prince' Billy - Keep Eye on Other's Gain (2008)
8. Neil Young - Revolution Blues (1974)
9. Tindersticks - Desperate Man (1997)
10. Damien Jurado - And Now That I'm In Your Shadow (2006)
11. Jean Ritchie - Barbary Allen (1961)
12. Sinéad O'Connor - Fire on Babylon (1994)
13. Bruce Springsteen - Black Cowboys (2005)
14. Current 93 - Hypnagogue IX (2003)
15. The Mountain Goats - Your Belgian Things (2004)
What do you think?
I think it is pretty neat! Maybe 4 out of 6 wizard hats (the secret 7th hat only being available to bands actually referencing Harry Potter), if I was to review it for some magazine counting things in that particular way. I decided not to overthink things and just pick what occured to me, according to how well it all fitted together in sequence. It could probably have been done a little better, but I am happy. I also tried to not go for the most obvious (to me) choices - so as to leave wiggle room for future lists, obviously.
Did you cheat in making your list, and if so, how and why?
I sort of cheated on two counts: Dan Savage and Moongazing Hare (# 1 and 2 on last.fm, no less) were taken off the list. The first because he is a podcaster and not a musician, the second because I only listen to myself so much in order to edit my own stuff. I almost took off Burial as well, since I am still getting acquainted with their "Untrue" album and making my mind up about it. HOWEVER, statistics being what they are, Burial stays on the list and I picked something that appealed to me!
Who almost made the list?
Shirley Collins, Ralph Stanley, Beth Gibbons & Rustin Man, The Pogues. All are sorely missed on there.